Army of the Cumberland and George Thomas Source -
www.AotC.net
..
....
Breechloading rifles of the
Civil War
Spencer, Maynard, Ballard, Burnside, Sharps,
Starr, Henry, Greene
plus the muzzle loaders Enfield, Springfield
and Whitworth, and the Minié ball
In cooperation with the of Newnan, GA
.
The Spencer repeater
(see spec chart below)
The most advanced infantry weapon in the world of its times, it was
patented in 1860 by Christian Spencer, a machinist who worked for Sharps
and developed the Spencer on his own time. It was the world's first practical
repeater and fired a .54 caliber metallic rimfire cartridge (patented by
Smith & Wesson and perfected by Henry in the late 1850's) which completely
prevented gas leakage from the back because the brass casing expanded on
ignition to seal the chamber. It had a "falling block" activated by lowering
the trigger guard. This movement opened the breech and extracted the spent
cartridge. Raising the lever caused a new cartridge to be inserted into
the firing chamber from a 7-round magazine in the stock. It was easy to
manufacture, had relatively few parts, many of which were in common with
the Sharps rifles, and was cheaper than other repeaters on the market such
as the Henry. It also turned out to be extremely reliable under battlefield
conditions. The great advantage over the muzzle loading rifles such as
the Enfields and Springfields lay not so much in the rapidity of fire,
but rather in the ability to aim each shot. In a battle situation, the
muzzle loaders were fired in an aimed manner only the first shot, thereafter
it was usually a case of hurried fire after frantic loading. A trained
soldier could get off one or two shot a minute with them. With the Spencer
the soldier could fire 20 to 30 times a minute when necessary. The only
disadvantage of the Spencers was the relatively small powder charge in
the cartridge which limited its range and made it less sought after by
infantry than the single shot Sharps breechloader which used paper or linen
cartridges. With the Sharps you could fire about 10 times a minute.
But for the cavalry which fought mostly at close range, the Spencer was
the weapon of choice. Introduced in Jan. 1862, it found its first major
use by Col. John Wilder's Indiana "Lightning Brigade" of mounted
infantry at Hoover's Gap during the Tullahoma Campaign
(22-29 June 1863). The firepower and speed of this unit overwhelmed Wheeler's
cavalry guarding the southern end of this pass and allowed George H. Thomas's
14th infantry corps to place itself on the flank of the Confederate General
Hardee. This sudden development misled Hardee into thinking he had
been suddenly outflanked by the entire Union Army of the Cumberland, and
he retreated without orders back to Tullahoma, 15 miles in his rear. This
in turn undermined Bragg's entire defensive line, and he had to pull back
into Chattanooga. At the price of about 500 casualties the Union Army advanced
100 miles and made military history.
| Between the rifle and carbine versions, about 48,000 of these weapons
were in use by 1865. The carbine was a shorter version of the Spencer 7-shot
repeating rifle and was introduced primarily for cavalry use in 1864. The
effective range (about 500 yards) was the same as the longer "rifle", but
it was more difficult to aim because of the relatively short distance between
the sights. Rest assured that very few marksman with the unaided eye could
or can reliably hit a man-sized target at more than 200 yards, regardless
of the effective range of the weapon. |
Click to
enlarge image.
|
| The Confederacy captured some of these weapons, but
was unable to manufacture the ammunition. It is only a small exaggeration
to state that this cartridge decided the outcome of the Civil War. |
.
.
|
Comparative table of the most common CW breechloaders
|
| Feature / model |
Sharps rifle |
Sharps carbine |
Spencer rifle |
Spencer carbine |
Henry rifle |
| Weight |
9.5 lb |
7.75 lb |
10 lb |
8.25 lb |
9.25 lb |
| Length |
47.inches |
39.inches |
47.inches |
39 inches |
43.5 inches |
| Breech.type |
falling block |
falling block |
falling block |
falling block |
collapsing toggle |
| Cocking |
hammer, hand |
hammer, hand |
hammer, hand |
hammer, hand |
self-cocking |
| Caliber barrel |
.52 |
.52 |
.52 |
.52 |
.44* |
| Ignition |
percussion cap |
percussion cap |
rimfire |
rimfire |
rimfire |
| Cartridge type |
linen |
linen |
metal |
metal |
metal |
| Bullet diameter |
.535 inches |
.535 inches |
.535 inches |
.535 inches. |
.455 inches |
| Bullet volume |
370 grains |
370 grains |
285 grains |
285 grains |
216 grains |
| Powder charge |
80 grains |
80 grains |
48 grains |
48 grains |
25 grains |
| Magazine |
none |
none |
butt,7 rounds |
butt,7 rounds |
under barrel, 15 |
| Rate of fire |
10 rounds/min. |
10 rounds/min. |
30 rounds/min. |
30 rounds/min. |
40 rounds/min. |
| Range** |
200/1000 yd. |
200/1000 yd. |
200/500 yd. |
200/500 yd. |
200/400 yd. |
| Intro. year |
1848 |
1848 |
1863 |
1864 |
1862 |
* This cartidge is equivalent to today's .44
caliber special which has more powder and a heavier bullet. The force of
the bullet upon arrival, measured in foot-pounds, is about the same. That
means that you can go out and buy for around $300 a modern Henry made by
Rossi (actually a copy of an 1892 Winchester), model 44 magnum, load up
to eleven .44 special cartridges in the magazine under the barrel) and
relive the shooting experience of a rich or lucky Civil War soldier, or
of a normal post-war settler or Indian.
**The effective range is difficult to establish
since so much depended upon the skill and training of the marksman. In
general the longer barrels of the "rifles" made sighting easier, thus improving
accuracy. However, with the unaided eye, very few people can hit anything
beyond 200 yards anyway. The other question is lethal range, i.e. how far
could the weapon throw a bullet with enough energy left in it to do damage?
This depended mostly on the powder charge and the weight of the bullet.
Other noteworthy Civil War era breechloaders
Maynard carbine
Single-shot rifled .50 caliber breechloader with a folding mechanism
(like a shotgun) using a metallic cartridge whose wide flange at the base
provided the gas seal. The weapon was invented by a New York dentist name
Edward Maynard. It was patented in 1851, and the barrel was unlocked by
lowering the trigger guard. The hammer was hand cocked, and ignition was
by means of a percussion cap whose spark fired the powder through a hole
in the center of the cartridge base. There was gas leakage through this
hole. Relatively few were manufactured and used in the Civil War, and those
mostly in the Confederacy. According to reports a practiced marksman could
be effective at up to 600 yards with the Maynard. The Confederacy was able
to manufacture the relatively simple Maynard brass cartridge (but not the
rimfire Spencer and Henry cartridges). The advantages of the Maynard were
its light weight at only 6 lbs and its simple construction.
Ballard rifle
Patented in 1861 by Charles H. Ballard of Sterling Massachusetts, it
fired a .44 caliber rimfire metallic cartridge. Single shot, accurate,
internal parts contained in the breech block with "camming" action. The
trigger guard is lowered to open the breech. After inserted the cartridge
the lever was then pulled up which closed the breech and half-cocked the
hammer. Pulling the small knob in the fore-stock (in the photo under the
sight) removed the spent casing. It was a well-made and effective
weapon, but the Spencer was more useful. After the war the Ballard became
a favorite with buffalo hunters.
Burnside carbine
General Ambrose Everett Burnside was born in 1824 and graduated from
the U. S. Military Academy in 1847. In 1853, then Lt. Burnside, a gifted
mechanical engineer, requested permission from the Secretary of War to
have the Springfield Armory construct a model of a firearm of his design
for the purpose of satisfying the "working model" requirement of the U.S.
Patent Office. His design, patented in 1856, had a roating breech block
and the advanced "gain-twist" rifling. A barrel with gain twist rifling
starts with a slow rate of twist at the breech of the barrel, but the rate
of twist is increased as the bullet reaches the muzzle. This feature increases
accuracy but is expensive to manufacture. To solve the problem of gas leakage
the Burnside breachloader used a special tapered .54 caliber metallic cartridge
which was shoved into the chamber by a plunger in the breach mechanism.
The operating lever was released by pressing the special small lever inside
the operating lever. By lowering the operating lever, which also served
as a trigger guard, a rectangular steel block was tlted up. This block
contained a cone shaped cavity into which the metallic cartridge
of the same shape was dropped with the bullet end up. By closing the lever
the block rotated forward and inserted the cartidge into the chamber. Smooth
insertion of the cartridge was facilitated by coating the casing with beeswax
or tallow. However, ignition was by percussion cap which fired through
a hole in the base of the cartridge which allowed some gas leakage. By
the end of the war, about 55,000 of the Burnside carbines had been delivered
to the US army. The requirements for the special cartridge limited the
usefulness of the Burnside.
Burnside went to become a well-known Union general who pioneered amphibious
landing techniques on Roanoke Island, NC in Feb. 1862. However, his
reputation is tarnished by a loss to Lee and Longstreet at Fredericksburg,
VA (13 Dec. 1862) and an undistinguished performance under McClellan at
Antietam (17 Sept. 1863). To be sure, at Fredericksburg Burnside had been
very poorly served by the War Department (which delayed consignment of
the necessary pontoon boats) and at Antietam by McClellan who, not even
present on the field, withheld an entire corps from the battle. Burnside
then did very good work at Knoxville, defeating a larger force under Longstreet
on 29 Nov. 1863. After the disaster of the mine explosion at Petersburg
in May 1864, a failure probably caused by Meade's and Grant's last minute
intervention to change the battle plan, Burnside was removed from active
command. After the war he served as governor of Rhode Island and then as
US senator from Rhode Island.

Sharps rifle and carbine (see spec chart
above)
Christian Sharps produced his first single shot, .54 caliber breech
loading rifle using paper cartridges in the late 1840's. Later the cartridges
were made of linen. The falling block, dropped by lowering the trigger
guard, cut off the end of the cartridge when the trigger guard was raised
to close the breech. Ignition was by percussion cap. During the prelude
to the civil war, the Rev. Beecher, an abolitionist, shipped Sharps rifles
to fellow abolitionists in Kansas in crates marked "Bibles". This gave
the Sharps rifle the nick-name "Beecher's Bibles". He was, by the way,
the brother of Harriet Beecher Stowe, authoress of "Uncle Tom's Cabin"
which was, in its way, just as effective as the rifles.
During the Civil War, the Sharps rifles, with their fast breech reloading
and their deserved reputation for accuracy, were in high demand. Col. Hiram
Berdan issued them to his notorious "Sharpshooters" who wore green
"camouflage" uniforms and were trained to fight behind cover. The maximum
effective range was about 1000 yards, less than that of the muzzleloading
Springfields and Enfields, but its breechloading mechanism allowed up to
10 shots a minute (as opposed to twice a minute with the muzzleloaders),
and the soldier could easily reload the Sharps in a prone, i.e. protected
position.
Starr carbine
A .54-caliber, single-shot, falling-block breechloading weapon on the
order of the Sharps, but less successful. Its block mechanism was complex,
and some of the parts were delicate and subject to breakage.
Henry repeating rifle (see spec chart above)
One of the first technicians involved with the development of repeating
rifles was Walter Hunt who received his patent in 1849 for a repeater with
a tube magazine under the barrel. The paper cartridges were to be inserted
into the chamber by lowering a lever which functioned also as a trigger
guard. This first attempt was called the "Volcanic". Benjamin Tyler Henry
of the company New Haven Arms Co. took this basic model and turned it into
the famous Henry
repeater
which was introduced onto the market in 1862. Henry held the patent, but
the the rights to the patent were held by his employer Oliver F. Winchester.
Described later by one Confederate as "that tarnation Yankee rifle they
load on Sunday and shoot all week," the Henry carried 15 rounds in its
magazine under the barrel. The rounds had to be inserted into the
front of the tube magazine. The breech mechanism is called a "collapsing
toggle" and is similar to that of the German Luger. With the Henry a lever
simultaneously cocked the rifle and ejected the spent case, and then put
a fresh cartridge in the chamber. The powder charge was located in the
copper-cased rimfire cartridges perfected by Henry himself in 1858 and,
like the Spencer's, was impervious to moisture. The primer was in
the cartridge's rim, placed there during the manufacturing process by spinning,
thus eliminating the need for external percussion caps. The caliber of
the barrel was .44. This cartidge is equivalent to today's .44 caliber
special which has more powder and a heavier bullet. The force of the bullet
upon arrival, measured in foot-pounds, is about the same. That means that
you can go out and buy for around $300 a modern Henry made by Rossi (actually
a copy of an 1892 Winchester), model 44 magnum, load up to eleven .44 special
cartridges in the magazine under the barrel) and relive the shooting experience
of a rich or lucky Civil War soldier, or of a normal post-war settler or
Indian.A hint: use the copper jacketed cartridges which clean the barrel
for you.
Another feature of the Henry was the forked firing pin which struck
the cartridge in 2 places, thus decreasing the possibility of misfires.
A disadvantage of the Henry was the relatively small powder charge (only
25 grains) which limited the Henry's range and penetration force. The magazine
at first was not a separate tube, as with the later Winchesters, but rather
machined together with the barrel out of one piece. Due to this machining
the Henry was also more expensive than the Spencer and more complicated,
and its frame and internal parts were made of brass which made them subject
to corrosion, and less robust and durable than the parts of the Spencer.
All of these factors limited the Henry's usefulness under battle conditions,
and about 10,000 of them were produced during the war. In fact, it really
came into its own after the war when it became the weapon of choice of
both settlers and Indians. The Army itself put it into the hands of the
Indians when it cleared out stocks preparatory to introducing a new version
with a steel body. The battle of Little Big Horn took place in the meantime,
and for once the Indians were better armed than the US cavalry under Custer.

The Greene breechloader
This was the only bolt action rifle used in the US during the Civil
War and, at the moment, I have no information about it other than this
picture. The Prussian bolt action "needle" rifle had been invented by Dreyse
in 1841. It's loading was gradually simplified, but until 1866, when rimfire
metallic cartridges were introduced in Europe, it used cartridges made
of cloth which a needle pierced in order to ignite the cap located between
the bullet and the powder. A future expansion of this article by Rico Fankhänel
of Dresden will deal with the needle rifle in detail.
Three other important infantry weapons of the
Civil War (muzzles loaders)
Enfield rifle musket
During the Civil War about 400,000 .58 caliber rifled Enfield Lock
muzzleloaders firing minié balls were imported from England by the
Confederacy during the war. About an equal number of them was imported
by the Union. They were manufactured by London Armory in England, or rather
under contract for London Armory (to avoid accusations of departure from
neutrality), and were generally of very high quality. However, since the
Confederacy paid with cotton bonds which became worthless, London Armory
went bankrupt after the war.
The
illustration shows a "trapdoor" breech, a modification of a muzzle loader
designed to turn it into a breech loader or, more accurately put, a rear-barrel
loader. Due to the expense, this was not a common feature of Civil War
infantry rifles.
Springfield rifle musket
During the Civil War about 2 million .58 rifled muzzleloaders firing
minié balls were manufactured in the Springfield, Mass. armory (established
by George Washington) or elsewhere under contract. The design was based
on that of the Enfield. Many of them were captured by Confederate soldiers
who then used them. This weapon was first introduced into the U.S. army
by Jefferson Davis when he was Secretary of War under Pierce. A practiced
marksman could hit a man with aimed fire at about 350 yards. Its large
bullet was capable of reaching 1500 yards with lethal force. Except in
the minds of many generals on both sides, this revolutionized warfare and
should have made mass frontal attacks, cavalry charges, and cannon placement
in the front line obsolete.
Whitworth rifle
A muzzle loading single shot percussion rifle manufactured in England,
it was highly prized by marksmen and imported in limited numbers by the
Confederacy. Outwardly it looked like an Enfield or a Springfield, but
a look in the barrel shows that it was much more sophisticated than they
were. It was very expensive for the times (about $100 each) and achieved
its legendary accuracy by means of a hexagonally shaped bullet and a spiraling
and hexagonally shaped bore which was difficult to machine, but was not
subject to fouling by powder residue as
were rifled bores. The bullet was also difficult to load, and this rifle
was used only by specialists. The Union general Sedgewick was reportedly
killed at Spotsylvania by a Confederate sharpshooter at 1800 yards (although
this distance may be an exageration), using a Whitworth equipped with a
telescopic sight which was generally mounted on the left side of the receiver.
The Whitworth's spiraling six-sided bore permitted the shaped bullet to
be made of harder alloy than lead and thus have a very high penetrating
power. The other round bore rifled muzzleloaders used the minié
type bullet (see below) which expanded under the pressure of the exploding
gases, thus filling the bore and engaging the rifling grooves. This required
that the bullet be made of relatively soft metal which tended to deform
under firing and to disintegrate upon striking the target. The breechloaders
had slightly oversized bullets which achieved the same effect.
The basis for most infantry
weapons was the minnie ball.
.
| About 90% of all battle wounds of the Civil War were
caused by the small arms projectile known as the minnie ball. Together
with the rifled bore, it changed the face of warfare forever. For the first
time in history, infantrymen could aim their weapons at a target a fair
distance away and actually have a good chance of hitting it. The days of
successful frontal assaults by infantry and cavalry should have been over,
and defenders armed with the new rifle-musket could fire from a safe place
and knock down attacker after attacker before they got close enough to
return the damage. Unfortunately most generals, including many famous ones,
were slow learners, so the days of unsuccessful
frontal assaults
by infantry were not over, but that is another story. |
 |
 |
The ball was perfected in 1849 by Captain Claude Minié of
the French Army. It was conical in shape and made of soft lead, with two
or three grease grooves around its body. The cylinder-conical ball had
a cavity at the rear. Upon firing, the hot gases produced by the burning
black powder charge expanded into the hollow cavity of the ball, forcing
the soft lead outward into the rifling grooves inside the barrel of the
musket. These grooves, which spiraled as they traveled the length of the
barrel, imparted a spin to the ball, making its range an incredible 1500
yards, with accuracy at up to about 350 yards. This design meant that the
bullet, being somewhat undersize before firing, did not have to be rammed
to the back of the barrel, which speeded up loading somewhat. The cartridges
consisted of the bullet and 60 grains of black powder enclosed in a paper
cylinder. The paper cylinder full of powder was placed behind the bullet,
both were wrapped in paper, tied off at the bullet end, and folded or twisted
closed at the powder end. To load this cartridge, the soldier would bite
off the folded end, pour the powder into the barrel, and squeeze the ball
from the paper wrapping. He would then ram the ball with the ramrod to
seat it on top of the powder. After a percussion cap was placed on the
nipple under the hammer, the musket was ready to fire. Expert marksmen
could complete the process in about half a minute. The Minié ball
was made primarily in .54, .58, and .69 caliber sizes which weighed from
1 to 1 1/2 ounces, and .50, .52, and .54 caliber conical projectiles were
used in various breechloading carbines. At 600 yards, a .58 caliber Minié
ball fired from a Springfield or Enfield rifled musket could penetrate
six 1 inch pine boards. When it hit the human body, destruction of tissues
and bone was massive. If a man was hit in the arm or leg, the bullet shattered
the bone from 6 to 10 inches and usually made amputation certain. If hit
in the torso, a man was usually left to die. The Civil War's deadliest
weapons were not rapid-fire guns or giant cannon, but the simple rifle-musket
and the humble minié ball.
The rifle-musket and minié bullet drastically altered the tactical
balance between an attacking army and a defending one. Frontal assaults
by infantry on a waiting enemy suddenly became suicidal. During the Napoleonic
era, attacking infantry could safely approach to within 100 yards of an
enemy line with little danger of being shot down. During the Civil War,
however, because of the rifle-musket's accuracy at long ranges, stationary
defenders could load, fire, and hit their advancing attackers more quickly
than they could fire back.
The combination of the rifle-musket and minié bullet also made
the bayonet obsolete. In earlier years, the bayonet was often the most
decisive infantry assault weapon, because the smoothbore flintlock musket's
short range allowed attackers to approach close enough for hand-to-hand
fighting. In the Civil War, however, firepower almost always decided an
assault's outcome before charging troops came within stabbing distance.
In fact, Civil War surgeons reported very few bayonet wounds.
The rifle-musket and minié bullet also forced a change in the
employment of field artillery. In the early 1800s, Napoleon often placed
the artillery forward in his battle lines, even during advances, to provide
direct fire in support of the infantry. This same tactic was used very
successfully by US forces during the Mexican War. During the Civil War,
however, it was too easy to shoot down an exposed cannon crew operating
in the front lines. The artillery thus had to be placed further to the
rear and protected. This made it more difficult to hit enemy targets without
endangering friendly troops in the front, but imaginative commanders were
able to solve the problem. In any case, the "flying" artillery batteries
had their wings clipped in the Civil War, at least where well-schooled
commanders were at work.
The role of the cavalry was similarly changed by the rifle-musket and
minié ball. Napoleon often used his cavalry as a surprise offensive
weapon, sending his horsemen on charges to trample infantrymen armed with
smoothbore flintlock muskets. But the Civil War soldier armed with a rifle-musket
and minié bullets could reliably hit a man at 100 to 200 yards,
while a horse and rider made an even easier target. As a result, the colorful
cavalry charges of the Napoleonic era became all but obsolete. In fact,
as the war continued, more and more cavalrymen fought as mounted infantry,
using their horses for mobility and then dismounting to fight on foot.
In effect, they became the forerunners of today's mechanized infantry.
Unfortunately, it took most Civil War generals very long to realize
that some of the tactics they had learned at West Point or from military
manuals were obsolete, particularly the frontal assault. Some never learned,
and Generals on both sides continued to send their men on suicidal charges
right up to the end of the war. Notable exceptions to this rule were the
Union generals Don Carlos Buell, William S. Rosecrans, and George H. Thomas
of the Army of the Cumberland. Some generals, such as Grant, perhaps realized
that the old tactics were no longer effective, but they apparently didn't
care, as long as they could count on a fresh supply of men. All the more
reason for you to study history, so as to be able to help choose intelligent
leaders who will protect your interests.
Send E-mail to
Das Spencer Magazingewehr
Das Magazingewehr
von Spencer hat die Kriegführung revolutioniert. Es feuerte eine metallische
randgezündete Patrone, die entweder aus einem 7 Geschosse enthaltenden
Rohr im Kolben geladen wurde (indem der Hebel ganz nach unten gezogen wurde),
oder direkt per Hand von hinten (indem der Hebel nur halb nach unten gezogen
wurde). Normalerweise versuchte der so ausgerüstete Soldat, die Patronen
im Magazin für den Notfall aufzusparen. Der große Vorteil
der Spencer-Gewehre lag nicht so sehr im schnellen Abfeuern, als in der
Möglichkeit, jeden Schuß damit gezielt abzugeben. In einer Gefechtssituation
konnte ein Vorlader nur einmal gezielt geschossen werden. Danach artete
es meistens in ein frenetisches Laden und Schießen ohne Zielen aus.
Mit einem Vorlader konnte ein geübter Soldat etwa ein oder zweimal
pro Minute schießen. Mit dem Spencer konnte man 20 bis 30 Mal pro
Minute schießen, als es darauf ankam. Ungleich dem Henry (Magazin
mit 15 Geschossen unter dem Lauf), mußte man den Hammer des Spencers
per Hand zurückziehen. Das Spencer war langsamer als das Henry, aber
einfacher, zuverlässiger unter Gefechtsbedingungen, und billiger in
der Herstellung, da es viele Teile gemeinsam mit dem berühmten Sharps-Gewehr
hatte (kein Wunder, da Herr Spencer nur abends sein Gewehr entwickelte.
Tagsüber arbeitete er bei Sharps). Das Spencer hatte auch die größere
Reichweite, da dessen Patrone mehr Schießpulver als die des Henry
enthielt. Der Süden hatte weder die Technologie noch die industrielle
Infrastruktur, um die Randfeuer-Metallpatrone herzustellen. Deshalb waren
die wenigen Spencers, die die Konföderierten erbeuten konnten, auch
auf erbeutete Munition angewiesen. Es ist keine große Übertreibung
zu behaupten, daß die Randfeuer-Metallpatrone den Ausgang des Bürgerkrieges
bestimmt hat. Der einzige Nachteil des Spencers war die relativ kleine
Pulverladung der Patrone, die die Reichweite des Spencers einschränkte.
Aus dem Grund zog die Infanterie den Sharps Hinterlader mit Papierpatronen
vor. Damit konnte man etwa 10-Mal in der Minute schießen. Das Spencer
blieb jedoch das Lieblingsgewehr der Union-Kavallerie.
Il fucile a ripetizione Spencer
Il ripetitore
Spencer rivoluzionò le operazioni belliche. Sparava una cartuccia
metallica con la carica fulminante nel bordo, che poteva essere caricata
da un
caricatore a 7 colpi situato nel calcio (tirando la leva completamente
in basso) o essere inserita direttamente nell'otturatore (dopo aver tirato
la leva parzialmente in
basso). Normalmente le truppe così equipaggiate cercavano di
conservare i colpi nel caricatore per le emergenze. Il grande vantaggio
rispetto ai fucili ad avancarica come gli Enfields e gli Springfields non
stava tanto nella rapidità di fuoco, ma piuttosto nella possibilità
di prendere la mira ad ogni colpo. In una situazione di battaglia i fucili
ad avancarica potevano essere usati prendendo la mira solo al primo colpo,
dopodiché si era costretti a sparare in tutta fretta dopo un caricamento
frenetico. Con essi un soldato addestrato poteva arrivare ad uno o due
colpi al minuto. Con lo Spencer il soldato poteva sparare fino a 20 o 30
volte al minuto, quando necessario. Diversamente dall'Henry (caricatore
a 15 colpi sotto la canna), il cane dello Spencer doveva essere riarmato
manualmente. Era più lento dell'Henry, ma più semplice e
di costruzione meno costosa, dato che condivideva molti pezzi con il famoso
fucile a retrocarica Sharps (questo non sorprende, dato che Spencer sviluppo
il suo ripetitore fuori orario. Durante il giorno lavorava per Sharps).
Lo Spencer aveva anche un tiro utile maggiore rispetto all'Henry, a seguito
della maggior carica di polvere delle sue cartucce. Il Sud non aveva né
la tecnologia, né la capacità industriale per fabbricare
le cartucce, così che i pochi Spencer che i Confederati furono in
grado di catturare (Forrest) dipesero interamente dalle munizioni prese
al nemico. Non è una grande esagerazione affermare che queste cartucce
decisero il risultato della Guerra Civile. Il solo svantaggi degli Spencer
era la carica di polvere relativamente piccola nella cartuccia, che limitava
il suo tiro utile e lo faceva meno desiderato dalla fanteria rispetto al
fucile a retrocarica a colpo singolo Sharps, che usava cartucce di cartone.
Con lo Sharps si poteva sparare circa 10 volte al minuto. Ma per la cavalleria,
che combatteva prevalentemente a distanza ravvicinata, lo Spencer era l'arma
ideale.
Le fusil à répétition de Spencer
Le fusil
à répétition Spencer révolutionna les opérations
militaires. Il tirait une cartouche métallique avec le détonateur
placé tout autour de la base à l'intérieur de la cartouche.
Le magasin logé dans la crosse contenait 7 cartouches qui étaient
introduites dans la chambre par un mouvement vers le bas du levier. En
faisant seulement partiellement ce mouvement il était possible d'insérer
une cartouche à la main directement dans la chambre, ce que les
tireurs faisaient normalement afin de conserver les coups dans le magasin
pour les situations critiques. Le grand avantage par rapport aux
fusils à baguette comme les Enfield et Springfield n'était
pas tellement la rapidité du feu, mais plutôt la possibilité
de viser chaque coup. Pendant la bataille le tireur pouvait normalement
viser seulement le premier coup. Ensuite il était contraint de tirer
à la hâte après avoir chargé frénétiquement.
Ainsi un tireur exercé pouvait arriver à deux coups à
la minute, tandis que le Spencer était capable de tirer 20 à
30 fois par minute au besoin. Le Henry (avec 15 cartouches dans le magasin
sous la canne) était plus rapide encore parce qu'il s'armait automatiquement
tandis que le chien du Spencer s'armait manuellement. Par contre le Spencer
était plus simple et plus robuste que le Henry. De plus la fabrication
du Spencer coûtait moins cher, parce qu'il avait beaucoup de petites
pièces en commun avec le fameux fusil à rétro-charge
Sharps, ce qui n'est pas surprenant du fait que Monsieur Spencer développait
son arme à répétition le soir et travaillait le jour
chez Sharps. Le Spencer avait une portée supérieure par rapport
à celle du Henry à cause de la charge supérieure de
poudre de ses cartouches. Le Sud n' avait ni la technologie, ni la
capacité industrielle pour fabriquer les cartouches métalliques
à fusée intérieure, donc l'utilisation des fusils
Spencer qui tombaient dans les mains des Confédérés
dépendait aussi des munitions capturées. Il n'est pas exagéré
d'affirmer que ces cartouches ont décidé toutes seules de
l'issue de la Guerre de Sécession. Il suffit de considérer
le rôle qu'elles et les Spencer ont joué à Tullahoma
et Chickamauga.